Ratepayers approved a $245,000 bridge, but the city engineer, R. H. Parsons, estimated the cost would be $300,000. Tenders were called for Peterborough’s high-level concrete bridge in late 1918, and ten companies looked at the plans. Three companies submitted tenders just before Christmas. Canadian Engineering and Contracting was low bid at just under $340,000. John Toole bid over $350,000, while R. Sheehy tendered at over $380,000. As the city elections were held always the first week in January, the outgoing council passed the decision to the 1919 city council.
After some cuts initiated by the politicians, Frank Barber’s bridge still had eleven arches. It would use 14,000 cubic feet of concrete, and 170 tons of reinforcing steel; the original plans had called for 17,000 cubic feet of concrete and 250 tons of steel. The central arch over the river stretched 234 feet from springer to springer, which at the time was the longest span on an open-spandrel concrete arch bridge built in Canada. Worldwide, thirteen such bridges had longer spans.